I was recently sent the essay Amy Chua wrote: “Why Chinese Mothers are Superior” by one of my best friends. I couldn’t even read it all the way through the first time, I was so incensed.
I was raised exactly that way, and all I can say is, my Chinese mother is incredibly inferior, and so is Amy Chua.
What a painful treatise to read, written by someone who’s haughtiness borders on Narcissistic Personality Disorder, if it’s not actually diagnosable. She basically spends the entire article talking about how her abuse of her two girls is justifiable because it makes her an excellent mother. I can tell you exactly why she wants her girls to succeed. She doesn’t give a rat’s ass about them. She just wants to be able to compare her girls to her Chinese mother friends’ children and say that they’re superior so that she can feel better about herself.
Because I started school early and skipped a grade, I was 11 during 8th grade. I once scored an 80 on a math test. My mother regularly went through everything in my room, including my papers and discovered the math test that I had brought home that day. She came out of my room right before dinner, waving the test in her hand, and said “get in the car.” I knew what was coming next. She was going to kick me out of the house.
She proceeded to tell me in the car that an 80 is a B-. A B- is one point away from a C. A C is average. And if I were to be average, I could not be her daughter nor would she acknowledge me. I might as well be dead because I was a waste of time and she regretted having me and the energy it had taken to raise me to that point. She then proceeded to take me, in the middle of winter and in the dark at 6 pm, to the cemetery. This was years ago before they used to lock up the entrances to cemeteries. She decided that I should be with “my people”, who were just as worthless as I was. Then she left me there. For half an hour. I was petrified, but because I was so used to the abuse, I knew that I had to develop some kind of plan. I had two choices: 1) try to figure out where I was, find a pay phone to call my godparents collect so they could pick me up or 2) prostitute myself so I wouldn’t starve to death on the streets. I knew this at 11 years old.
She came back afterward to find me walking down the road from the cemetery in the direction of the nearest payphone, and was angry at me for not “staying put”. She said I was a horrid child for scaring her into thinking something might have happened to me. Are you fucking kidding me?
This pattern repeated itself time and time again, with all different types of inventive emotional and physical abuse.
Did it work? According to Amy Chua, yes. I went to an ivy league school, I secured a very successful job in corporate, easily made six figures before I was 30. But I went to therapy for years, continue to loathe my mother and resent my father for locking himself downstairs in his office while she beat me relentlessly and he could hear everything. The only time he intervened was when I was 13 and she was choking me for going out to a movie without her permission. I had started to black out before I heard him in the room.
What I know for sure is that when Amy Chua’s father looked at her and said, “Garbage”, he was absolutely right. I think she should re-read this article to herself in forty years when she is dying alone in a nursing home. It might give her some clarity when the aides call her daughters to tell them “it’s time” and she wonders why no one shows up.
